Our All-Time Favorite Thanksgiving Sheet Cakes

Break up the surplus of pie this Thanksgiving—gather your guests around the dessert table and let them eat cake. Sheet cake, that is. Perfect for the busy host, these one-layer wonders make use of your trusty 13×9-inch pan, coming together in a cinch for a dessert that feeds and pleases the masses. From a butterscotch cake we refer to as the Eighth Wonder of the World, to our pear cake with a luscious shaved chocolate topping, these sheet cakes are anything but flat.

  1. Maple-Pecan Apple Cake with Maple Buttercream

To give this cake a richer maple flavor, we use Grade B maple syrup, which has a stronger profile than Grade A. The label of your syrup bottle will detail which grade your syrup is.

2. Pear Cake with Whipped Chocolate Ganache

A hint of cardamom lends a little heat to this rich buttermilk batter swirled with a fragrant pear spread. Unlike jam, fruit spreads don’t have any added sugar, so they lend a more natural, delicate sweetness to baked goods. If you like your cake extra sweet, though, jam works just as well.

Italian Cream Sheet Cake

3. Italian Cream Sheet Cake

This sheet cake is our answer to those Italian Cream Cake cravings when time is short. Each bite crunches with buttery pecans and sweet coconut flakes, complemented by a swooping layer of whipped cream on top.

4. Butterscotch Cake with Salted Caramel Buttercream

Finished off with a silky Swiss meringue buttercream and a generous pour of salted caramel, this sheet cake is pure butterscotch bliss.

5. Browned Butter Apple Poke Cake with Cream Cheese Icing

The secret to this apple-intense poke cake? Boiled Cider, a tangy reduction of fresh apple cider. Take a bite of this tender cake, and you’ll find the best kind of surprise: pockets of tart boiled cider syrup hiding under a thick coat of cream cheese frosting. Don’t miss our guide on more ways to spice up your fall baking with boiled cider!

6. Texas Sheet Cake

The reigning king of all sheet cakes, this easy Texas Sheet Cake is a chocoholic’s dream. A rich, fudgy cake cloaked in warm chocolate frosting with a sprinkling of pecans for added crunch? Yes, please!

7. Bourbon-Walnut Brown Sugar Cake with Mascarpone Buttercream

There’s nothing like a little bourbon to warm the soul when the weather turns cool and crisp, which is why we let the aromatic Kentucky-made spirit star in this grown-up version of your favorite brown sugar cake. Mascarpone thickens and brings a slight tang to the frosting.

8. Pumpkin Spice Gooey Butter Cake

Inspired by the gooey butter cake of St. Louis, Missouri, this Pumpkin Spice Gooey Butter Cake has two textured layers: a chewy brown sugar base and a filling so rich with butter, eggs, and pumpkin purée that the middle sinks down into a creamy, custardy valley.

Previous articleMultigrain Dutch Oven Bread
Next articleWinter Tree Cookies


Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.